| ANDREWS, IDA R. | (M) | Nov. 1894 by certificate | Moved Oct 1896 | |
| ANDREWS, JOHN W. | (S) | Nov. 1894 by certificate | Moved Oct 1896 (Pastor) | |
| ANDREWS, LYDIA | (M) | Oct. 1896 | Moved Oct 1896 | |
| ANNIN, FRANK | (S) | | Moved 27 Ross Pl. Auburn | |
| ANNIN, HOWARD | (M) | Jan 24, 1897 by certificate | Moved 27 Ross Pl. Auburn | |
| ANNIN, SARAH | (W) | | Died October 27, 1905 | More than 60 years a member. The oldest member at the time of her death. |
| ANTHONY, CLAIRE | | | Dropped | |
| ANTHONY, CLAUDE | | | To Union Springs Mar. 1927 | |
| ANTHONY, CORDELIA D. | (W) | | Died Jan. 1922 | |
| ANTHONY, D. W. | (M) | | Died Oct 25, 1910 | |
| ANTHONY, E. M. | (S) | Jan 4, 1914 from probation | Letter to Union Springs 1926 | |
| ANTHONY, G. W. | (M) | | Died | |
| ANTHONY, MALINDA | (W) | | Died Aug. 9, 1912 | |
| ARMITAGE, A. WESLEY | (M) | May 3, 1903 by certificate | Letter June 13, 1908 | |
| ARMITAGE, JESSIE M. | (M) | May 3, 1903 by certificate | Letter June 13, 1908 | |
| ARNOLD, MARGARET EMALINE | (S) | 1876 | Died Nov. 11, 1906 | |
| AXTON, MRS. WILLIAM | (M) | July 17, 1921 letter from Fosterville | | |
| AXTON, WILLIAM | (M) | July 17, 1921 letter from Fosterville | | |
| BAILEY, ANNA | (M) | Jan 6, 1914 Letter | To Buffalo without letter | |
| BAITY, GEORGE R. | (M) | Died June 22, 1907 | | |
| BAITY, HARRIET | (M) | Died Aug 11, 1900 | | |
| BAITY, JOHN | (M) | Died July 1917 | | |
| BAITY, SARAH | | | To 9 Ketchell St. Auburn | |
| BAKER, EDNA | | | | (See Tavenor new book) |
| BAKER, MILDRED | (S) | Jan 6, 1914 from Probation | | |
| BAKER, MILDRED F. | (S) | July 4, 1914 | | |
| BAKER, MINNIE | (W) | | | |
| BAKER, MRS. F. (MINNIE) | (W) | | Deceased | |
| BAKER, MRS. WARREN | (M) | Sep 20, 1903 from Probation | | |
| BAKER, WARREN | (M) | Sep 5, 1897 from Probation | | |
| BALDWIN ELIAS | (M) | | Died Feb. 1902 | |
| BALDWIN, CHARLES | (S) | | Removed without letter | |
| BALDWIN, EMMA | (M) | | Letter: Seneca Falls May 1902 | |
| BALL, MRS. GEORGE | (M) | June 14, 1915 by letter | 1916 to 1st Church Auburn | |
| BEATTIE, EDWARD | (M) | Sep 5, 1897 from Probation | Letter to Fosterville | |
| BEATTIE, MARY | (M) | Sep 5, 1897 from Probation | Deceased | |
| BELL, ELIZABETH | (M) | | Died Ovid Asylum | |
| BELL, JOHN | (M) | | Died Apr 20, 1908 | |
| BLAUVELT, MARY E. | (W) | | | |
| BOARDMAN, ETHEL | (M) | Letter Sep 9, 1898 | | |
| BOYD, LAURA(?) W. | (M) | Oct 1904, Pastor’s wife | To Manlius | |
| BREEZE, JESSIE | (S) | Jan 2, 1916 by letter | Removed | |
| BREEZE, MRS. BERTHA | (M) | Jan 2, 1916 by letter | Removed | |
| BROWN, CHARLOTTE | (W) | | Died 1901 | |
| BROWN, HARRY | (S) | | Letter Oct 15, 1900 | |
| BUSH, BERTHA | (M) | May 5, 1901 by Letter | Certif: June 1918 Weedsport | |
| BUSH, HAROLD | (S) | March 15, 1914 from Probation | To Weedsport abt. 1915 | |
| CALDWELL, MRS. | | | Letter to half-way Jordan | |
| CARNEY, ANDREW | (M) | Sept. 29, 1895 from Probation | | |
| CARNEY, HELEN | (M) | | Died June 30, 1914 | |
| CASTNER, SARAH | (M) | July 1,(no entry) | | |
| COAPMAN, JANE | (M) | Died May 1922 | | |
| CODDINGTON, ARTHUR | (S) | Jan 9, 1921 Letter from Buffalo | To Fosterville | |
| CODDINGTON, ETTA | (S) | Jan 9, 1921 Letter from Buffalo | To Fosterville | |
| CODDINGTON, JOSEPH | (S) | Jan 9, 1921 Letter from Buffalo | To Fosterville | |
| CODDINGTON, PEARLE | (S) | | | |
| COFFINGER, ELSIE | (M) | Sep 25, 1910 Letter from Baptist | To Waterloo Dec 4, 1911 | |
| COLE, HENRY | (M) | May 19, 1895 Letter F. Meth. | Died Sept 30, 1906 | |
| COLE, SARAH | (M) | May 19, 1895 Letter F. Meth. | Died Dec. 12, 1913 | |
| CORNELIUS, FRANK | (M) | July 17, 1921 from Fosterville | | |
| CORNELIUS, FRANK T | | Sep 17, 1916 | To Sennett without letter. | |
| CORNELIUS, MRS. FRANK | (M) | July 17, 1921 from Fosterville | | |
| CORNELIUS, PAULINE | | | | |
| CORNELIUS, WILBUR | | | | |
| CORNELIUS,GLADYS | | | | |
| CROFUT, MARTHA | (M) | | | |
| CROFUT, MATTIE | (M) | (carris?) June 30, 1889 from Probation | Deceased | comment: “See old record 1859. Helen Stienberg(?) by some means overlooked.” |
| CROFUT, STEPHEN | (M) | | Died March 7, 1897 | |
| DEWEY MAY | (M) | Sept 22, 1895 from Probation | Letter Dec 15, 1902 | |
| DEWEY, BURTON | (M) | Sept. 22, 1895 from Probation | Letter Dec 15, 1902 | |
| DEWEY, GUY M. | (M) | March 13, 1910 from Probation | July 22, 1911 to Freeville NY | |
| DEWEY, MAUDE A. | (M) | March 13, 1910 from Probation | July 22, 1911 to Freeville NY | |
| DICKSON, ELISHA | (M) | | Withdrew Jan 24, 1901 | |
| DICKSON, J. M. | (W) | | Letter June 29, 1907 | |
| DICKSON, NELLIE A. | (M) | | Deceased | |
| DICKSON, SARA MOSES | (M) | | Letter June 29, 1907 | |
| DILLAN, ALICE | (S) | April 12, 1914 from Probation | To Seneca Falls NY | |
| DILLAN, MILDRED | (S) | April 12, 1914 from Probation | To Seneca Falls NY | |
| DILLON, CLARA | (M) | April 28, 1916 from Probation | To Seneca Falls NY | |
| DODGE, HARRISON | (S) | Oct 26, 1915 by letter | To Nyack Sept 1916 | |
| DUNDON, HARRIET | (W) | June 7, 1908 by letter | | |
| DUNDON, JANE (Harriet) | (M) | Nov 26, 1899 by letter | Letter Nov 23, 1906 | |
| DUNDON, RUTH | (M) | June 7, 1908 by letter | Deceased | |
| DUNDON, WILLIAM | (M) | June 7, 1908 by letter | Died Feb 7, 1912 | |
| DUNDON, WILLIAM | (M) | Nov 26, 1899 by letter | Letter Nov 23, 1906 | |
| EGGLESTON, MISS | | | Deceased | |
| FINNEY, AUGUST C | (M) | Oct 4, 1908 by letter | Letter to Minoa Sep 21, 1927 | |
| FINNEY, AUGUSTUS | (M) | | Apr. 23 1897 by letter | |
| FINNEY, CHATHARINE | (M) | | Letter to East Syracuse | |
| FINNEY, GEORGE | (M) | June 30, 1889 from Probation | Decesaed | |
| FINNEY, GUY | (M) | June 14, 1891 from Probation | Removed without letter | |
| FINNEY, MARTHA | (W) | May 29, 1917 by letter | | |
| FINNEY, MRS. KITTIE | | | Letter to Minoa Sep 21, 1927 | |
| FINNEY, OLAND | (S) | | Transferred to Phoenix | |
| FINNEY, RAYMOND | (S)(M) | Sep 5, 1897 from Probation | Letter to Wash DC Sep 1919 | |
| FORSHAY, C. M. | (S) | Jan 4, 1916 from Probation | Deceased | |
| FREAR, MARY | (W) | | | See Ridley |
| FREESE, (MCGONEGAL) CARRIE M | (S)(M) | Sep 22, 1895 prob. | Died April 30, 1917 | |
| FREESE, MARTHA | (W)(Revised) | May 29, 1917 by letter | Deceased | |
| FREESE, MARTHA | (M) | | By letter to Auburn | |
| FREESE, P.C. | (M) | | Died May 13, 1901 | |
| FREESE, PEARL | (S) | Sep 22, 1895 from probation | Mar. at Rochester, letter 1903 | |
| FREESE, SADIE | (S) | | Died Jan. 1923 | |
| GILBERT, ELSIE M. | (S) | June 17, 1906 from Probation | Letter to Woodbridge 9/11/1908 Married Irving Valentine | |
| GILBERT, ELSIE M. | (S) | June 17, 1906 from Probation | Letter to Woodbridge 9/11/1908 Married Irving Valentine | |
| GILBERT, LOUIS | (S) | June 17, 1906 from Probation | Letter Nov 23, 1906 Cortland | |
| GULLEY, EMMA | (M) | Sep 29, 1895 from Probation | Discontinued | |
| HAIM, NELLIE WARD | (M) | | Letter to Eastwood | |
| HALE, CHRISTINA HOWARD | | Oct 4, 1908 by letter | Letter to Black River? Dec 16, 1909 | |
| HALE, PROF. A. L. | | Oct 4, 1908 letter | Letter to Black River? Dec 16, 1909 | |
| HAMBLIN, PAMELIA | (W) | | Letter Ocean Grove NJ Dec. 15, 1902 | |
| HAMILTON, (FINNEY) ADA | (S)(M) | April 11, 1897 prob. | Certif Feb 20, 1912 | |
| HAMILTON, DELLA | (M) | Dec 29, 1895 Certif. | Certif Sept 23, 1901 | |
| HAMILTON, FRANC | (M) | | Letter Feb 17, 1898 | |
| HAMILTON, HELEN | (M) | Sept. 22, 1901 by letter | Letter to Montezuma June 27 1906 | |
| HAMILTON, JOSEPH | (M) | April 11, 1897 from probation | see new book | |
| HAMILTON, JOSEPH W. | (S) | April 11, 1897 from probation | letter Apr. 14, 1908 to Good Will Congregation Syracuse | |
| HAMILTON, LIBBIE | (M) | | Died May 25, 1904 | |
| HAMILTON, MRS. JOSEPH (ORPHA) | | 4/11/1897 prob. | | see new book |
| HAMILTON, ORPHA | (M) | April 11, 1897 from probation | | |
| HARRIS, CHARLOTTE | (M) | Sep 29, 1895 from probation | Died at Schenectady January 1918, buried Cayuga Jan 23 | |
| HARRIS, GILBERT | (M) | Sep 29, 1895 from Probation | Died at Sennett | |
| HEBBLETHWAIT, JAMES | (M) | Oct 1901 by letter | Pastor’s family | |
| HILIKES, ELIZA | (W) | | Died Nov. 2, 1910 | |
| HILIKES, ETHEL | (S)(M) | Sep 22, 1895 from Probation | letter 1898 Married F. Boardman (see “B”) | |
| HILLIKER, DORA B. | (M) | March 3, 1918 from Probation | Letter to Woodlawn M.E. Church | |
| HOOD, RAY | (S) | April 12, 1914 from probation | | see new book |
| JOHNSON, MRS. JENNIE | (W) | Nov 22, 1908 letter from Ithaca | Letter to Senece 1909 | |
| KELLEY, MRS. WILLIAM | (W) | March 1, 1920 letter from Elbridge | Died 1921 | |
| KELLEY, MRS. WILLIAM W. | (M)(W) | March 8, 1910 | Letter to Sennett Congr. 1918 | |
| KELLEY, WILLIAM | (M) | March 8, 1910 | Died Feb 21, 1912 | |
| LAMB, E. H. | (M) | | Died Mar 19, 1919 | |
| LAMB, MARY F. | (M) | | | New book |
| LEE, LUVINIA | (M) | | | New book |
| LEE, NELLIE WALKER | (M) | | Jan 30, 1918 Trans. St. John’s Auburn | New book |
| LEE, ROBERT | (M) | | | New book |
| LEE, SUSIE (Mrs R.) | (M) | | | New book |
| MAIN, I OR T?.G | (M) | Jan. 2, 1916 by letter | Letter to Cortland | |
| MAIN, MARION | (S) | Jan 2, 1916 by letter | Letter to Cortland | |
| MAIN, MRS. NETTIE | (M) | Jan 2, 1916 by letter | Letter to Cortland | |
| MAIN, REUBEN | (S) | Jan 2, 1916 by letter | Letter to Buffalo May 1917 | |
| MARSH GENEVIEVE | | | | New book |
| MARSH MRS. GEORGE | (M) | Sept 20, 1903 from prob. | | New book |
| MARSH, BURNACE | | | | New book |
| MARSH, ETHEL | | | Married Baldwin | |
| MARSH, GEORGE (BUDDY) | | | | New Book |
| MARSH, HAZEL | | | Dead | |
| MARSH, JENNIE | (M) | | | See Tavenor |
| MARSH, JENNIE TAVENOR | (M) | | Letter East Syracuse | |
| MARSH, LEWIS | (S) | March 13, 1910 from probation | Trans. Waterloo Dec 30 1913 Back Nov 29, 1914 Letter 1st Ch Cleveland O. Nov 1916 | |
| MARSH, VIOLA | | | Married Endsworth and Joined Presbyterian | |
| MCDONALD MRS. GRACE (EBER?) | | | | New book |
| MCDONALD, EBER T. | (S) | Sep 5, 1897 from probation | | |
| MCDONALD, FRANK | (M) | May 26, 1912 certif from Dresden NY | Letter to Elyria Ohio | |
| MCDONALD, JOHN | (M) | | Removed without letter | |
| MCDONALD, JOHN JR. | (S) | Sep 5, 1897 from probation | Removed Throopsville | |
| MCDONALD, MARY | (M) | | | |
| MCDONALD, MRS. FRANK | (M) | May 26, 1912 certif from Dresden NY | Letter to Elyria Ohio | |
| MCDONALD, MRS. SAM | (M) | April 12, 1914 from prob. | | |
| MCGONEGAL, CARRIE M. | (M) | | Letter to Rochester: See Freese | |
| MOONIE, CARRIE | (M) | | Died Apr 5, 1896 | |
| MOONIE, NELLIE (CROFUT) | (M) | March 6, 1881 from probation | Died Aug 29, 1906 | |
| MOSES, SARAH | (W) | | Deceased | see Dickson |
| MOSHIER, BERTHA | (M) | | To Hopwell & Flink? Apr 26, 1911 | |
| NOONIN, EMMA | (S) | | Letter May 10, 1900 | |
| ODELL, ELIZABETH | (M) | | Married G. Myers | |
| ODELL, GEORGE | (M) | | Died Aug 31, 1913 | Heart and Stomach Troubles |
| ODELL, LELAND | (S) | Jan 4, 1914 from prob | Letter Nov 1921 | |
| ORNAND, MARY | (S) | | | New book |
| PEASE, CHARLOTTE | (W) | Blauvelt | Died July 7, 1920 | |
| PURINGTON, SUSI A. | | | Pastor’s family | |
| QUIGLEY, HAROLD | (M) | Apr 10, 1926 by letter | | New book |
| RELFE, G. B. | (M) | Jan 4, 1914 from prob. | Rejoined on prob 1927 | |
| RELFE, MABEL R. | (S) | Dec 31. 1905 from prob. | New book | |
| RELFE, MRS. G. B. | (M) | Jan 4, 1914 from prob. | Dead | |
| RIDLEY, BETTY | | | Child (infant) | |
| RIDLEY, MARTHA | | | | New book |
| RIDLEY, MRS. S.(ZADA) | (M) | May 24, 1917 by letter | | New book |
| RIDLEY, OLAND | | | | New book |
| RIDLEY, STEVEN | (M) | | Dead | |
| RIDLEY, ZADS? | (M) | May 29, 1917 by letter | | See Finney |
| ROGERS, MARY | | Sept. 29, 1895 from prob. | Letter to Glenwood Roch. | |
| ROGERS, PHILIP J. | (M) | Sept 29, 1895 fm. prob. | Letter to Glenwood Rochester Nov 26, 1902 | |
| SANDERS, ANN | (S) | | | New book |
| SECOR, ROSE (MRS. WM) | (M) | March 20, 1918 Certif Wall St. Auburn | | New book |
| SECOR, WILLIAM Nelson | (M) | March 20, 1918 Certif. Wall St. Auburn | | New book |
| SHANK, JOTHAM W. | (M) | | Deceased | |
| SMITH, FLORENCE MAY | (M) | March 5, 1918 from probation | | New book |
| SMITH, RUTH WILEY | | | Removed NY City | |
| SMITH, TRACY | (M) | April 10, 1926 by letter | Removed without letter | |
| SMITH, TRACY MRS. | | April 10, 1926 by letter | Removed without letter | |
| STANLEY, CORA | (M) | | June 9, 1896 by Certif | |
| STANLEY,L. M. | (M) | | June 9, 1896 by Certif | |
| STEINBERG (MCAURTHUR), MAY | (S)(M) | | Certif to Fair Haven Aug 30, 1912 | |
| STEINBERG (STEENBURGH), CARRIE | (M) | | | New book |
| STONEBURGH, ADDIE MAY | (M) | | Certif to Geneva July 1918 | |
| TAVNER, (BAKER) EDNA | (S)(M) | Sep 20, 1903 from probation | | See Baker |
| TAVNER, (MARSH) JENNIE | (S)(M) | Sep 20, 1903 from probation | Married George Marsh | |
| TAVNER, ARLENE | | | | |
| TAVNER, BESSIE (WHITCOMB) | (S)(M) | Sep 20, 1903 prob. | Died March 11, 1905 | |
| TAVNER, FRED | (M) | | | |
| TAVNER, GEORGE | (M) | March 15, 1914 from probation | | New book |
| TAVNER, HARVEY | | | | |
| TAVNER, LAURA (MRS. GEORGE) | (M) | March 15, 1914 from probation | | New book |
| TAVNER, MRS. FRED (DELIA) | (M) | Sep 20, 1903 from probation | | New book |
| TAVNER, MRS. GEORGE (LAURA) | (M) | March 15, 1914 from probation | | New book |
| TAYLOR E. ROY | | Jan 1, 1909 | Pastor’s family | |
| TAYLOR SARAH E. | (M) | Sept 21, 1902 from probation | New Book, to Presbyterian | |
| TAYLOR, ELIZABETH | (S) | Sep 21, 1902 | Died Jan 14, 1910 Married James Morgan of Syr. | |
| TAYLOR, FLORA B. | | Jan 1, 1909 | Pastor’s family | |
| TAYLOR, LESTER W. | (S)(M) | Sep 20, 1903 from probation | Letter to Syracuse | |
| TAYLOR, MARTHA H. | | Jan 1, 1909 | Pastor’s family | |
| TEMPEST, FLORENCE S. | (M) | Jan 25, 1918 Certif from Palmyra | Watertown, back to Paymyra | |
| TERWILLIGER, ADA | (M) | | Letter August 13, 1898 | |
| TERWILLIGER, IDA | (W) | Apr. 10, 1926 Certif from Fair Haven | | New book |
| TOWNSEND, BERTHA E. | (M) | Sept 20, 1914 with letter | Deceased | |
| TOWNSEND, JOHN E. | (M) | April 18, 1915 from probation | Letter toTrinity Ch. Auburn | |
| WALTERS, MILDRED R. | (S) | July 17, 1921 from probation | Married J Mullen New book | |
| WARD, ADDIE MAY | (S) | Sep 5, 1897 from probation | | See Stoneburgh |
| WARD, HELEN | (M) | | Died May 16, 1917 | |
| WARD, NELLIE | (S) | Sep 5, 1897 from probation | By certif. | Mrs Heim? |
| WARD, THOMAS | (M) | | Died Aug 5, 1918 | |
| WARNER, ESTHER J. | (W) | Jan 1902 by letter | Letter June 13, 1908 | |
| WARRICK HANNAH | (M) | Oct 24, 1915 prof of faith | Dead | |
| WARRICK, HENRY | (M) | Oct 25, 1915 prof of faith | Died Dec. 24, 1918 | |
| WARRICK, HERBERT J. | (M) | May 5, 1901 by letter | Letter May 11, 1905 | |
| WARRICK, LYDIA E. | (M) | May 5, 1901 by letter | Letter May 11, 1905 | |
| WATERS, CLARA L. | (M) | Jan 4, 1914 Reclaimed | Died Oct 9, 1914 | |
| WATERS, GEORGE M. | (M) | Jan 4, 1914 from probation | Letter to Seneca Falls 11/29/1927 | |
| WATERS, HARRIETT M. STEWART | (M) | Jan’y 28, 1918 from Gloversville | Dead ?Waterloo | |
| WEBB, CHARLOTTE | (M) | Nov 3, 1895 probation | Letter Dec 1896 | |
| WEBB, ERNEST | (M) | Nov 3, 1895 probation | Letter Dec 1896 | |
| WELLS, JOSEPH | (W) | Oct 2, 1911 transfer | Died Oct 2, 1912 Pastor’s father | |
| WELLS, LOUISA m. | (M) | Oct 2, 1911 transfer | Pastor’s wife | |
| WHITCOMB, CATHARINE | (M) | | Died Dec 31, 1908 | |
| WHITCOMB, CHARLES | (M) | | Died March 1908 | |
| WILEY (GROVER), MATIE | (S)(M) | | Letter to Berkshire NY Dec 24, 1908 | |
| WILEY ELMER | (S) | Jan 4, 1914 from probation | U.S. Army 1917 | |
| WILEY FRED | (S)(M) | | Removed Kenwood/Buffalo | |
| WILEY, H. S. | (M) | | Died June 18, 1916 on Children’s Day | Pastor’s Father |
| WILEY, JASON L. | (S) | Sep 5, 1897 from probation | To Fair Haven Nov 17, 1912 | |
| WILEY, LOUIS | (M) | June 17, 1906 probation | Deceased | |
| WILEY, LUCINA | (S) | Sep 5, 1897 from probation | Married W. C. Chamberlain | moved to S. Onondaga, Pastor’s wife |
| WILEY, LUCY | (S) | Apr 4, 1915 from probation | Rem. Seneca Falls | |
| WILEY, RUTH | (S) | April 4, 1915 from probation | Married W. H. Smith | |
| WILEY, SCOTT | (S)(M) | | | New book |
| WILEY, URANIA | (M) | | | New book |
| WILLEY, MRS. A. C. | (M) | October 1916 | Pastor’s family | |
| YAWGER, LAURA | (M) | | Dead | |